Roofing Materials Compared: Which Is Most Durable and Cheapest?

Latest Comments

No comments to show.
Which Roofing Material is the Most Durable?

For Melbourne homes the main roofing materials are concrete tiles, terracotta tiles and Colorbond steel. Terracotta is the longest-lasting and holds its colour for life; concrete tiles are durable and cost less but their surface needs recoating over time; Colorbond is the cheapest to install and suits low pitches. Published Melbourne re-roofing rates run about $84 to $190 per square metre for Colorbond, $105 to $230 for concrete tiles and $135 to $275 for terracotta.

The short answer

  • Terracotta: longest-lasting, colour for life, highest cost
  • Concrete tiles: durable, cheaper than terracotta, surface needs recoating over time
  • Colorbond steel: cheapest to install, light, suits low pitches
  • Brickworks offers up to 100-year warranties on terracotta and 50 and 100-year structural warranties on concrete
  • Changing material usually needs a building permit and a frame check

Roofing materials compared

Terracotta tilesConcrete tilesColorbond steel
Re-roof cost, Melbourne$135 to $275/m²$105 to $230/m²$84 to $190/m²
DurabilityBrickworks: up to 100-year product warrantyBrickworks: 50 and 100-year structural warrantiesLong-lived; check the manufacturer’s warranty for your area
Colour over timeHolds its colour for lifeSurface coating fades and can be recoatedFactory finish; can be recoated with metal coatings
WeightHeavyHeavyLight
PitchNeeds a pitched roofNeeds a pitched roofSuits low pitches and skillions
Typical repairsMatched tile replacement, rebed and repointRecoat, rebed and repoint, tile replacementFixings, sheet replacement, rust treatment

Costs are What’s The Damage’s Melbourne re-roofing ranges including strip-off, verified October 2026.

About these prices

These are market ranges from published Australian price guides, not Royce Roofing prices. Every roof is different. We give you a fixed written quote after a free inspection.

Sources: What’s The Damage: Roofing costs in Melbourne (October 2026); Brickworks: Reasons to choose terracotta roof tiles; Brickworks: Reasons to choose concrete roof tiles.

Which roofing material is the most durable?

For a pitched roof, terracotta is generally the longest-lasting covering: fired clay does not fade, and Brickworks backs its terracotta tiles with a product warranty of up to 100 years. Concrete tiles are also very durable structurally, with Brickworks offering 50 and 100-year structural warranties, but the surface coating wears and needs renewing. Whatever the covering, the ridge capping, valleys and flashings wear out first, so durability in practice depends on maintenance. See how long a tiled roof lasts.

Sources: Brickworks: Reasons to choose terracotta roof tiles; Brickworks: Reasons to choose concrete roof tiles.

Weighing up a new roof?

Book a free inspection. We will tell you honestly whether to restore, re-tile or change material.

Which is the cheapest roof?

On published Melbourne re-roofing rates, Colorbond is usually cheapest to install, concrete tiles sit in the middle and terracotta costs most. But the cheapest roof to own is the one that suits your house and gets maintained. Restoring a sound tiled roof, at about $4,200 to $11,550 on published Melbourne figures, is usually far cheaper than replacing it with anything. See our restoration cost guide.

Sources: What’s The Damage: Roofing costs in Melbourne (October 2026).

Choosing tiles on a budget

  • Concrete tiles cost less than terracotta and can be recoated in any colour later
  • Second-hand tiles, around $4 per tile plus GST at our yard, are an economical way to repair or extend an older roof
  • Restoring the roof you have usually beats replacing it
  • Spend on the parts that keep water out: bedding, pointing and valleys

See second-hand roof tile prices.

Changing materials

Replacing tiles like for like generally does not need a building permit in Victoria, but changing the roof covering usually does. Tiles are much heavier than sheet steel, so moving between them means checking the roof frame, and heritage overlays can limit what you can use. Talk to your council and roofer first.

Sources: BPC: When is a building permit required? (BP-01); City of Monash: Roofing renovations.

Bushfire-prone areas

If you are in a bushfire-prone area, the roof is one of the most important parts of the house to get right: gaps under tiles and in gutters let embers in. CSIRO’s bushfire research covers retrofits for roofs, including sealing gaps and keeping gutters clear. Your bushfire attack level determines what the building code requires for new work.

Sources: CSIRO: Bushfire retrofits for roofs; CFA: Start preparing your property for fire season.

What Royce works with

Royce Roofing specialises in tiled roofs, terracotta and concrete, and stocks over 200 tile types across our Mulgrave and Doveton yards. See terracotta roof tiles, concrete roof tiles and roof replacement.

Our own rail, every job

WorkSafe Victoria’s compliance code for housing construction puts edge protection such as guard railing ahead of harnesses and ladders when controlling the risk of falls from a roof. Our crews set up our own temporary safety rail, ladder guards and, where there are old skylights, safety nets before anyone works on the roof. Every crew member holds a working at heights qualification.

Common questions

What is the most durable roofing material?

For pitched roofs, terracotta is generally the longest-lasting, with Brickworks offering up to a 100-year product warranty. Concrete tiles are also structurally durable but their surface needs recoating over time.

What is the cheapest type of roof?

On published Melbourne re-roofing rates, Colorbond steel is usually cheapest to install, then concrete tiles, then terracotta.

Are concrete or terracotta tiles better?

Terracotta lasts longest and keeps its colour; concrete costs less and can be recoated. Both are long-lasting when the capping, valleys and flashings are maintained.

Can I change from tiles to Colorbond?

Usually, but it generally needs a building permit, and heritage overlays may limit it. The roof frame should be checked when changing materials.

Which roof tiles last the longest?

Terracotta tiles generally last longest. Brickworks backs its terracotta tiles with a product warranty of up to 100 years.

What roof tiles should I choose on a budget?

Concrete tiles cost less than terracotta. For repairs and extensions on older roofs, second-hand tiles are an economical option.

Sources: What’s The Damage: Roofing costs in Melbourne (October 2026); Brickworks: Reasons to choose terracotta roof tiles; Brickworks: Reasons to choose concrete roof tiles; BPC: When is a building permit required? (BP-01); City of Monash: Roofing renovations; CSIRO: Bushfire retrofits for roofs; CFA: Start preparing your property for fire season.

Dave Porter

Dave Porter

Qualified roof tiler. Owner and Managing Director, Royce Roofing. Founder, PorterVac.

Dave Porter is a qualified roof tiler who has run roofing businesses in Melbourne since 2000. He founded PorterVac, the vacuum gutter cleaning and roof maintenance business, in 2004, and has led Royce Roofing as owner and managing director since 2018. A working at heights safety advocate and educator, Dave introduced the safety and training programs Royce crews follow on every roof.

TAGS

CATEGORIES

Roofing

Comments are closed

Call 1300 992 911